「基準の確立 → 例外の報告と反論 → 基準への疑問」という科学論争の型です。第2段落は Critics argued と Lindqvist countered で 誰の主張か を分けてメモします。最終問は not A so much as B の B が答えです。
Since the American psychologist Gordon Gallup first placed a mirror in front of chimpanzees in 1970, the mirror self-recognition test has been regarded as the closest thing comparative psychology possesses to a benchmark for self-awareness. The procedure is deceptively simple: an animal is marked, typically with a spot of dye on a part of its body it cannot otherwise see, and researchers observe whether it uses the reflection to investigate the mark. Great apes, dolphins, elephants, and magpies have all passed in at least some trials, and for decades the exclusivity of this club was taken to confirm that a sense of self was the preserve of large-brained, socially sophisticated species. Failure, by contrast, was routinely interpreted as evidence that an animal simply lacked the cognitive machinery in question.
That tidy picture was disturbed when a team led by Tomas Lindqvist reported that the cleaner wrasse, a small reef fish with a brain a fraction the size of a walnut, appeared to scrape a colored mark against rocks after viewing itself in a mirror. The claim provoked an unusually sharp response. Critics argued that the fish might merely have been reacting to an irritating sensation, or that the mark resembled the parasites the species habitually removes from other fish, so that the behavior reflected instinct rather than insight. Lindqvist countered that his subjects ignored transparent marks and did not scrape when no mirror was present, conditions which, he maintained, rule out the most obvious alternative explanations and satisfy precisely the criteria that had hitherto been applied to apes without objection.
The dispute has exposed a deeper problem than the abilities of any single species. If the wrasse genuinely passes, researchers must either concede that self-awareness is far more widely distributed than assumed or acknowledge that the test measures something less profound than they had believed. A growing number of scientists favor the latter conclusion, contending that mirror behavior sits on a continuum and that a single pass-or-fail threshold obscures gradations that matter. Others note that the test is heavily biased toward visually oriented animals; a dog that fails in front of a mirror may nevertheless distinguish its own scent from that of others with ease. What is emerging, then, is not a verdict on fish so much as a recognition that the tools used to study animal minds have themselves been insufficiently examined.
Q11 / 3
According to the passage, why was the mirror test considered so significant?
根拠:the exclusivity of this club was taken to confirm that a sense of self the exclusivity of this club was taken to confirm that a sense of self に続く「大きな脳を持ち社会的に洗練された種だけのもの」が根拠です。exclusivity of this club → limited to a small group、large-brained, socially sophisticated → highly intelligent, social の言い換えです。合格者が限られていたからこそ、自己認識の基準として重みを持ったという因果を読み取ります。 - チンパンジーは最初に 合格した 側で、失敗した実験という記述はありません。 - 合格したのは Great apes, dolphins, elephants, and magpies などごく一部で、every animal は正反対です。 - 脳の大きさを測るテストではなく、脳の大きさは合格種の 特徴 として後から結びつけられたものです。
Q22 / 3
What did Tomas Lindqvist say in response to his critics?
根拠:satisfy precisely the criteria that had hitherto been applied to apes without objection Lindqvist countered that 以降が彼の反論で、satisfy precisely the criteria that had hitherto been applied to apes without objection が根拠です。criteria hitherto applied to apes → standards long accepted for apes、satisfy → met の言い換えです。透明な印を無視した事実や、鏡なしではこすらなかった事実は、この主張を支える証拠として挙げられています。 - 印を寄生虫と見間違えたというのは 批判者側 の主張です。 - 小さな脳の魚に洞察は期待できないという発言はなく、むしろ Lindqvist はその逆を示そうとしています。 - 本文は did not scrape when no mirror was present で、鏡がなければこすらなかった、が正しい内容です。
Q33 / 3
What does the author suggest about the current state of the debate?
根拠:the tools used to study animal minds have themselves been insufficiently examined 最終文 the tools used to study animal minds have themselves been insufficiently examined が根拠です。tools used to study animal minds → research methods、insufficiently examined → need closer examination の言い換えです。not A so much as B の B に筆者の結論が置かれています。 - 自己認識が広く分布している 可能性 に言及するだけで、all vertebrates で証明されたとは述べていません。 - 犬は「鏡には落ちても匂いなら区別できる」という テストの偏り の例で、魚との優劣は論じていません。 - a single pass-or-fail threshold obscures gradations と、単一の閾値はむしろ批判されています。