In 2021, the council of a mid-sized Spanish city launched a two-year experiment in which through traffic was banned from a cluster of nine residential blocks. Residents’ cars and delivery vehicles were still permitted, but only at walking speed, and intersections inside the zone became small plazas with benches and planting. The council presented the scheme mainly as a public health measure, arguing that its central aim was to 1. Monitoring stations installed before the trial had recorded nitrogen dioxide levels well above the limits recommended by the World Health Organization, and the district had one of the highest rates of childhood asthma in the region.
The environmental results were largely as expected. Within a year, nitrogen dioxide inside the zone had fallen by about a quarter, and evening noise levels dropped noticeably. What surprised the planners was the effect on the streets bordering the zone, where they had feared that displaced traffic would 2. Instead, total vehicle counts in the surrounding area fell by roughly eight percent, suggesting that some drivers had switched to buses or bicycles, or had simply combined trips rather than seeking an alternative route.
The social outcomes have proved harder to measure and more controversial. Surveys found that residents inside the zone spent more time outdoors and reported knowing more of their neighbors by name. 3, business owners on the edge of the zone complained that customers who used to arrive by car had stopped coming, and a group of them petitioned the council to reopen two of the streets. Rents inside the zone have also risen faster than the city average, raising concerns that the very people the scheme was meant to protect may eventually be priced out. The council has extended the trial but has not yet made it permanent.