原田英語の英検二次面接 ぜんぶ攻略くん
AI採点

英検1級 二次 予想トピック 51 ・ 🌏 国際・観光・多文化 ・ Is ~?

Are economic sanctions an effective way to change a country's behavior?

経済制裁は、ある国の行動を変えさせる効果的な方法か。

このトピックを選ぶべき人

国際紛争のニュースを追っていて、具体的な国の例を出せる人向け。

骨組み理由3つ（どちらの立場でも話せる）

賛成（Yes）で話すなら

I believe economic sanctions can be effective, especially when many countries act together.

  1. peaceful pressureSanctions allow countries to put pressure on others without using military force. This makes them a much less costly option than war.
  2. past successSanctions have sometimes contributed to real change. International sanctions against South Africa, for example, are often said to have helped bring an end to apartheid.
  3. clear messageEven when sanctions do not change a government's behavior immediately, they show that the international community will not accept serious violations. This can discourage other countries from doing the same thing.

反対（No）で話すなら

I don't believe economic sanctions are generally an effective way to change a country's behavior.

  1. ordinary peopleSanctions often hurt ordinary citizens more than their leaders. Shortages of food and medicine may affect the poor, while the ruling elite remains comfortable.
  2. ways around themCountries under sanctions can often find other trading partners. Russia, for example, has continued to sell energy to some major countries despite Western sanctions.
  3. stronger leadersSanctions can allow leaders to blame foreign countries for economic problems. This may actually increase public support for the government.

想定質疑面接委員はこう突っ込んでくる

QIf not sanctions, what other options do countries have?

That's a fair question. I'm not saying sanctions are useless in every case. However, they work best when combined with diplomacy, such as negotiations that offer clear rewards for changing behavior. On their own, I don't think they are enough.

Q：制裁でないなら、各国にはどんな選択肢がありますか。
A：もっともな質問です。制裁がどんな場合も無意味だと言っているわけではありません。しかし、行動を変えればはっきりした見返りがある交渉など、外交と組み合わせてこそ最も効果を発揮します。制裁だけでは不十分だと思います。

QCould sanctions be designed to avoid hurting ordinary people?

Yes, to some extent. Targeted sanctions, such as freezing the overseas assets of leaders, are better than broad trade bans. Still, it is hard to target only the leaders, so ordinary people often suffer anyway.

Q：一般の人を傷つけない制裁を設計することはできますか。
A：はい、ある程度は。指導者の海外資産を凍結するような対象を絞った制裁は、幅広い禁輸よりも優れています。それでも指導者だけを狙うのは難しく、結局は一般の人が苦しむことが多いのです。

QShould Japan join sanctions imposed by its allies?

In most cases, I think it should, because acting together makes sanctions more effective and shows unity. However, Japan also needs to consider its own energy needs and economic situation. It's a matter of balance.

Q：日本は同盟国が科す制裁に加わるべきですか。
A：ほとんどの場合は加わるべきだと思います。一緒に行動すれば制裁はより効果的になり、結束も示せるからです。ただし、日本は自国のエネルギー事情や経済状況も考える必要があります。バランスの問題です。

語彙このトピックで使える表現