原田英語の英検二次面接 ぜんぶ攻略くん
AI採点

英検1級 二次 予想トピック 11 ・ 🤖 テクノロジー・AI ・ To what extent

To what extent should AI be trusted to make important decisions about people?

人に関わる重要な判断を、AIにどの程度任せてよいか。

このトピックを選ぶべき人

採用・医療・融資などの具体的な場面を思い浮かべて話せる人向け。

骨組み理由3つ（どちらの立場でも話せる）

賛成（Yes）で話すなら

I believe AI can be trusted to a large extent, as long as humans check its decisions.

  1. consistencyAI does not get tired or emotional, so it can apply the same standards to everyone. Human decisions, such as hiring, are often affected by personal bias or mood.
  2. accuracyIn some fields, AI already performs as well as experts. For example, AI systems can help doctors spot signs of cancer in medical images that humans might miss.
  3. efficiencyAI can process huge amounts of information in seconds. This allows professionals to spend more time on the parts of their work that require human judgment.

反対（No）で話すなら

I believe AI should be trusted only to a limited extent, because its decisions can be biased and difficult to explain.

  1. hidden biasAI learns from past data, which may contain discrimination. One well-known recruiting tool was reportedly found to favor male applicants because it had been trained on past hiring records.
  2. black boxMany AI systems cannot explain why they reached a certain decision. When people are refused a loan or a job, they deserve a clear reason.
  3. accountabilityIf an AI makes a serious mistake, it is unclear who should take responsibility. Final decisions that affect people's lives should be made by humans who can be held accountable.

想定質疑面接委員はこう突っ込んでくる

QWhat if the AI makes a mistake that ruins someone's life?

That's exactly why human oversight is essential. Admittedly, AI will sometimes be wrong. However, I'm not saying AI should make final decisions alone. My point is that AI can give a recommendation and a human should check it, especially in serious cases.

Q：AIが誰かの人生を台なしにするような間違いをしたらどうしますか。
A：だからこそ、人間による監督が欠かせないのです。確かに、AIが間違えることはあるでしょう。しかし、AIだけで最終判断をすべきだと言っているのではありません。AIが提案を出し、特に重大な場合には人間がそれを確認すべきだ、ということです。

QHow can we prevent AI from being biased?

First, companies should check the data they use and test their systems regularly for unfair results. It would also help to have independent organizations audit AI systems. Humans are biased too, so the goal is not perfection but fairer decisions than before.

Q：AIが偏らないようにするには、どうすればよいですか。
A：まず、企業は使うデータを確認し、不公平な結果が出ていないか定期的にシステムを検査すべきです。独立した機関がAIシステムを監査するのも有効でしょう。人間にも偏りはあるので、目指すのは完璧さではなく、これまでより公平な判断です。

QWould you accept a job rejection made by AI?

Honestly, I would feel uncomfortable if no human was involved at all. However, if AI was only used to screen applications and a person made the final decision, I would accept it. What matters most is that I could get a clear explanation.

Q：AIによる不採用の判断を、あなたは受け入れますか。
A：正直に言えば、人間がまったく関わっていなければ納得できないと思います。でも、AIは書類の選考に使うだけで、最終判断を人が下すなら受け入れます。いちばん大切なのは、はっきりした説明を受けられることです。

語彙このトピックで使える表現